A Scots nurse who was suspended after she objected to sharing a changing room with a transgender doctor has claimed she “did not see any signs of distress” after a row, a tribunal has heard.
Sandie Peggie, who has worked at the Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife, for 30 years was put on leave then suspended in January 2024 after a complaint by Dr Beth Upton, a trans woman, following the incident on Christmas Eve in 2023.
Ms Peggie was accused of bullying and harassment, but went on to lodge her own complaint of sexual harassment or harassment related to protected beliefs under section 26 of the Equality Act 2010, regarding three incidents where she shared the female changing room with Dr Upton. She claimed that being made to get changed beside the doctor amounted to unlawful harassment.
On Wednesday, February 5, Ms Peggie gave evidence at an employment tribunal in Dundee and said her line manager had advised her to speak to Dr Upton.
She had previously told the tribunal she felt “embarrassed and intimidated” following the incident on Christmas Eve. However, this was disputed by NHS Fife, who described the case as “unnecessary and vexatious”.
Judge Alexander Kemp said: “I understand from what you said that you were aware (Dr Upton) might be using the changing rooms.”
Ms Peggie said: “It was just chitchat at work. It was being discussed. The staff members were just chatting about Beth and that he was a trans woman. I had mentioned ‘as long as he’s not getting changed in a female changing area’.”
Giving evidence, she said she spoke to her line manager, Esther Davidson, in August 2023, and told the tribunal: “I was hoping she would give advice and speak to someone in management or HR.”
Ms Peggie said she later asked what the outcome was, and added: “She had spoken to equality and diversity and if I was in that situation again I would have to speak to Beth.”
After an incident in October 2023 when she was partially undressed and Dr Upton walked in, Ms Peggie spoke to her line manager, the tribunal heard.
She was suspended after raising the issue with Dr Upton on Christmas Eve 2023 and previously told the tribunal she was “embarrassed” due to menstruation, and she insisted was not drawing comparisons with a convicted rapist when she likened the situation to a “biological man in a women’s prison”.
She claimed she was not familiar with the case of transgender rapist Isla Bryson, who was jailed for eight years in 2023 for raping two women pre-transition, and was initially placed in an all-female prison before being transferred to a male facility.
Join the Daily Record’s WhatsApp community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages.
Cross-examining, Mr Kemp said: “Did you see any visible signs of distress?”
Ms Peggie said: “No.” The nurse’s husband, Darren Peggie, gave evidence and said on Christmas Day 2023 his wife appeared “embarrassed and upset” when she got home from work.
Mr Peggie said: “She had a discussion with Dr Beth, she was quite upset. She was telling me in the morning. She was upset, she was embarrassed, then started opening Christmas presents.
“She said she went to changing rooms and he was in there. I think it might have been a heavy period. He was there and she was embarrassed. She was upset. She was trying to be okay for the kids and that and then went upstairs.”
Mr Peggie was asked if he had “strong opinions on trans people” during cross-examination by Jane Russell KC, representing Dr Upton and Fife health board. He said: “I’ve got strong views on everything.”
One of the couple’s children also gave evidence, and said: “Mum came in obviously upset, we spoke about what had happened on her shift the night before.
“She told me that there was an altercation in the changing rooms the night before with a man present. She told me she went into change because she had bled, she walked in and there was a man and she felt intimidated and embarrassed.”
Representing Ms Peggie, barrister Naomi Cunningham said: “Was this the first you’d heard about a particular doctor getting changed?”
The woman said: “I’d heard previously but just that there was a man in the changing rooms.”
Founder of campaign group Sex Matters, Maya Forstater, gave evidence and said: “Our position is not that men are dangerous predators, but that men as a group are a risk, and men who identify as trans women continue to form part of that group.”
She said the organisation “recognises there are two sexes and our objective is to promote human rights”.
Ms Forstater said comments made by a campaigner about “keeping down the number of people who transition” was in the context of “the recent rapid increase in children and young people transitioning”, the tribunal heard.
The tribunal is being heard publicly after a successful argument by Ms Peggie, despite requests from NHS Fife and Dr Upton that it be held in private to protect the identities of those involved. Ms Peggie has also been permitted to refer to Dr Upton as male, as long as it was not done “offensively” or “gratuitously”.
The tribunal continues.
Don’t miss the latest news from around Scotland and beyond – Sign up to our daily newsletter here.