A second suspect has been collared in the the killing of a 57-year-old woman during the robbery of her husband outside their Lower East Side apartment last year, police said Friday.

Joshua Bell, 19, was extradited to the city following his arrest earlier this week in South Carolina, police said.

He will be charged with murder, police said, for the Sept. 9 shooting inside victim Ying Zhu Liu’s apartment building on Market St. near Madison St.

A pool of blood in the hallway of the Market St. apartment building where Ying Zhu Liu was fatally shot during an armed robbery on Monday, Sept. 9, 2024. (Colin Mixon for New York Daily News)
A pool of blood in the hallway of the Market St. apartment building where Ying Zhu Liu was fatally shot during an armed robbery on Sept. 9, 2024. (Colin Mixon for New York Daily News)

Bell was part of a trio of masked stickup men who followed Liu’s husband, 61, into the building and onto the elevator, police said.

The victim was robbed of $100 in cash and his cellphone, cops said. As the elevator opened up on the eighth floor, they were greeted by Liu’s 31-year-old son, Lin Rong Yan, who neighbors know as Paul.

“Stay back! They have a gun!” Liu’s husband said before Paul jumped into the elevator to save his father.

“Paul came out,” a neighbor who watched surveillance footage of the clash but didn’t want to be identified said after the killing. “Paul and his father were scuffling with them.”

Ying Zhu Liu (pictured) was killed after her husband was followed into the couple's building on Market St. near Madison St. by the pair of muggers, both wearing ski masks, and onto the elevator about 11 p.m. on Monday, September 9, 2024, cops said.
Ying Zhu Liu was killed after her husband was followed into the couple’s building on Market St. near Madison St. by the trio of muggers, all of whom wore ski masks, and onto the elevator about 11 p.m. on September 9, 2024, cops said.

During the fight in the elevator, the teens dropped the gun, but managed to scoop it up as the father and son forced the muggers to the opposite end of the hallway from their apartment and through a stairwell door, prosecutors said.

After they went through the door, Liu can be seen on video running down the hall from the direction of their unit. She entered the stairwell door and then moments later collapsed back through it, said the neighbor.

“It was one shriek, then another shriek and then I heard a pop,” the shocked building resident said. “Then I heard more commotion and yelling.”

The gunman shot Liu in the face from less than 3 feet away as the brawl continued, prosecutors said after the first arrest, of a 16-year-old boy, less than two weeks after the murder.

NYPD 6th Precinct officers are seen outside building located at 44-46 Market Street in the Chinatown area of Manhattan early Tuesday September 10, 2024. Last night a pair of crooks trying to steal a cell phone from a resident shot and killed the wife of the victim in the face. As the husband struggled with the robbers his wife, Ying Zhu Liu, stepped out of the couple's apartment and was shot in the right cheek by one of the muggers. She died at the scene. A single shell casing was recovered in the stairwell but the killer crooks ran off with the husband's cell phone and have not been caught. (Luiz C. Ribeiro for New York Daily News)
NYPD officers outside Market St. building on Lower East Side after Ying Zhu Liu was killed inside the location last year. (Luiz C. Ribeiro for New York Daily News)

A third suspect is still being sought.

Originally Published: March 21, 2025 at 3:53 PM EDT

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts


This will close in 0 seconds